Saturday, April 7, 2018

115. "The Leader in Me." by Stephen Covey



242 pages. 

Reviewed by J. d'Artagnan Love

The Leader in Me is a program implemented in K12 school systems based on Covey's book The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People. This program is implemented in most of the schools in my local community with at least one of the schools being categorized as a "Lighthouse" school. A Lighthouse school is, apparently, a school that has reached a certain level of sponsorship and implementation of the this program. 

This book, The Leader in Me, describes how this program started at A.B. Combs Elementary school. Essentially, the principal at A.B. Combs wanted to make the school a magnet school focused on fostering leadership skills. Covey's ideas weren't the only ideas she used but, instead, she pulled from the work of leaders all over the world to build the program. The concepts were interwoven into the culture of the school and results seems to indicate increased teacher satisfaction, improved test scores, and reduced discipline issues. 

I read this book as part of a research project I'm working on so it is hard for me to give a "review" in terms of quality for the general reader. I'd say this is definitely interesting stuff for educators and parents to comb through, but you should also be aware that this isn't the only program out there doing great things in schools. There is actually a lot of controversy surrounding the Leader in Me program especially when it comes to the cost of implementing the program through the official sponsoring organization

Overall, the book does a good job describing the program, its roots and how to implement it. The bias is quite obvious so readers definitely need to use critical thinking skills when determining whether this is something to consider for their own school systems. 

RECOMMENDED FOR: K12 educators, parents, and researchers interested in education. Just keep the bias in mind and don't let it blind you.

NOT RECOMMEND FOR: The general public--it isn't a book to read unless you have a specific interest in education. 

3 darts out of 5



Saturday, March 24, 2018

114. "Speak" by Laurie Halse Anderson


Halse Anderson, Laurie. Speak. New York: Puffin, 2001.

208 pages.

Reviewed by J. d'Artagnan Love

Popular among teens right now is the Netflix original series 13 Reasons Why based on the book by Jay Asher.  Having watched the series myself, but not read the book, I"m going to venture an educated guess that Speak is far better. It addresses the same kinds of themes but more tactfully and with less misogyny. 

In Speak, Melinda is dealing with a trauma, the origins of which aren't revealed until later in the book. She deals with this trauma by withdrawing into a dark place. She stops speaking, thus the title of the book. It is through the help of a teacher and some of her own inner resilience that she is able to work through her limitations. 

This lyrical novel reminds me slightly of Francesca Lia Block's style in the Weetzie Bat series. It has the same lyrical quality but where it differs is in the concrete story line and absence of magical realism. Laurie Halse Anderson has an unmistakable voice that is consistent throughout the story. 

I appreciated this story and felt it was a germane representation of trauma and the resulting depression and anxiety. I'm looking forward to reading it again. 

4 darts out of 5

Recommended for: readers who liked 13 Reasons Why. This is better.

No recommended for: readers who are sensitive to depictions of mental illness, readers who don't like lyrical writing, and readers sensitive to sexual themes. 

Saturday, March 10, 2018

113. "The Adventures of Alice in Wonderland" by Lewis Carroll

(Image Source)

Carroll, Lewis. Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. New York: Sterling Publishing, 2005.

129 pages.

Reviewed by J. d'Artagnan Love

Most people know of this classic children's story. Most people also cheapen Alice's journey through Wonderland by claiming the story is just one big acid trip. While it is fantastical and full of whimsy, the story of Alice's Adventures in Wonderland is much more political and social commentary than it is an acid trip.

In sum, Alice, a little girl follows a rabbit down a rabbit hole. This leads her to a series of adventures that are hard to believe. For example, in one scene, Alice enters the rabbit's house and drinks a potion that causes her to grow so large, she sticks one hand out the chimney and a foot out the door. A cat with a Cheshire grin seems to float through the air because he can make parts of his body invisible at will. The story is dizzying and disorienting and makes almost no sense. 

I enjoyed reading the book but I'll be the first to admit that fully appreciating this work is going to require that I do much more extensive research. A brief survey of the literature on this work points to Carroll indulging in a style called English nonsense verse that became fairly popular in his time. Carroll holds some scathing opinions about the English school system based on this tale and that is about as far as I've gotten with my research. 

The edition that I read appeared to only contain the first part of the story (Alice's Adventures in Wonderland) so I need to find the second half and read it (Through the Looking Glass) and continue to read more about how scholars have made sense (as much as one can with the genre) of the writing to feel like I truly "get" Carroll. I'm not yet a frenetic fangirl, but I am intrigued and will keep exploring. 

Recommended for: a reader who has time to dedicate to really learning about the political and social discourse happening in these stories.

Not recommended for: readers who want a story that makes sense or readers not accustomed to searching for clues in writing. Someone who hates poetry, for example, would probably hate this.

3 darts out of 5

Reference
Kwoka, B. (2009).  Literature, History, and Culture in the time of Victoria. Retrieved from http://www.victorianweb.org/authors/carroll/kwoka8.html

(I know I'm mixing citation styles here but I primarily use APA but started this blog in MLA and try to stay consistent. Forgive me?)



Saturday, February 3, 2018

112. "Storm Front" by Jim Butcher


Butcher, Jim. Storm Front. New York: Penguin, 2000.

322 pages

Reviewed by J. d'Artagnan Love

Harry Dresden is both a wizard and a private investigator. He takes a job with the local Chicago PD investigating a murder in which two people's hearts exploded out of their bodies. This was murder by magic and Dresden is set with the task of figuring out who could have the power to do such magic. 

The novel is a fun genre mashup of standard mystery novel formula meets urban fantasy. The pace keeps the reader interested and there is also enough detail provided to understand the world creation and magic system. Told from Dresden's first person perspective, the writing is both intimate and witty. A cast of characters is skillfully built to develop a series of additional novels. I was left wanting to learn more about the cast and to see which adventure Harry would be met with next. Overall, this was a quick, engaging read. It wasn't a literary masterpiece but it was an entertaining 322 pages. 

Recommended for: readers who enjoy a good urban fantasy suspense. Adult readers (some sexually explicit and violent themes I wouldn't recommend for children and teens).

Not Recommended for: Kids and teens or anyone wanting a book that has lyrical or masterful prose. Expect prose that is plot oriented and meant to entertain. 

3 darts out of 5

Friday, January 19, 2018

111. "White Oleander" by Janet Fitch


Fitch, Janet. White Oleander. New York: Little Brown and Company, 1999.

390 pages

Reviewed by J. d'Artagnan Love

Twelve year old Astrid's mother killed a man and now Astrid is in foster care. For Astricd, foster care is the exact nightmare that every child pictures. Trauma follows trauma. That is essentially the story. As I read, I wondered if perhaps Janet Fitch sat down and asked herself: in how many ways can I torture a teenage girl? White Oleander was created as her resounding answer.

Fitch's writing is lyrical in some ways, redundant in others. At times, her prose took my breath away. At others I rolled my eyes after the eleventh simile on a single page. Her greatest strength in this novel was character development. The characters were rich, deep, and clearly individuals. Sometimes you read a book and the characters all kind of blend together. That didn't happen in White Oleander. Each character had a unique way being in the world as is represented by Astrid's "museum" at the end of the novel. The book is not so much a story with a conflict and resolution, but more of a character map. For me, this is interesting and kept my attention. Perhaps it is my background in psychology--the Velcro loop for Fitch's hook. If you don't enjoy a deep dive into the mind of a character, or prefer novels that are plot driven, this isn't the book for you.

Overall, it is a commendable work for a debut novel.

4 darts out of 5

Sunday, January 7, 2018

110. "One for the Money" by Janet Evanovich


Evanovich, Janet. One for the Money. New York: St. Martin's Press, 1994.

320 pages

Reviewed by J. d'Artagnan Love

SYNOPSIS: 
After getting laid off, Stephanie Plum takes a job as a bounty hunter working for her cousin, Vinnie. Her $10,000 FTA (failure to appear) is Joe Morelli, a police officer accused of shooting and killing an unarmed man. Stephanie and Joe have a history dating back as early as grade school but bringing him in isn't easy. Stephanie finds herself in the cross-hairs of a sadist boxer who enjoys abusing women and gets in a little over her head her first day on the job.

WHAT I LIKED:
I liked that the crime solver (Stephanie) was something other than a police officer or forensic pathologist. I've read so many mystery series where this is the standard. It's rare to find someone outside these roles be the protagonist in a mystery series.

I liked that the characters were dynamic and interesting. Of particular interest to me were Stephanie, Ranger, and Grandma Mazur. I will also admit to liking the standard mystery novel format. I like the rhythm of the genre and figuring out whodunnit (which I did pretty easily with this novel).

WHAT I DIDN'T LIKE:
Why, why, why does the mystery genre always have to include a story line about a sadistic man who abuses and assaults women in almost every novel? In One for the Money, Benito Ramirez is that man. The man who dos unspeakable things to women. The archetype of the criminal misogynist. Why is this constantly the trope? There are so many interesting things a writer can do with a mystery, so many different crimes to choose from. One of the reasons I like the recently deceased Sue Grafton is that her stories are outside the box of constant mysteries about assault on women. She writes about arson and burglary and other crimes. It takes some true grit and creativity to pull off a story that doesn't center around a misogynist. I had hoped that Evanovich would rise to this challenge and she failed miserably.

That being said, I did still enjoy the book enough to be curious about the next book in the series.

RECOMMEND FOR:
Readers who like a standard mystery novel.

NOT RECOMMENDED FOR:
Women sensitive to stories about sexual violence.

3 darts out of 5

Sunday, October 29, 2017

109. "Hunger" by Roxane Gay




Gay, Roxane. Hunger: A Memoir of (My) Body. New York: Harper Collins, 2017.

304 pages.

Reviewed by J. d'Artangnan Love

SYNOPSIS: Hunger is about Gay's experience with her fat body. Fat is used here not as an expletive but merely a descriptive word like "tall," and "short" are descriptive words. Gay explains her experience with food and fatness that, for her, stem from being raped as a child and not dealing with the trauma in a healthy way.

WHAT I LIKED: Roxane is incredibly brave to put herself out there in a memoir. It is clear that this book outlines the most vulnerable parts of herself. This is something not many people can do, and I certainly applaud her for this.

WHAT I DIDN'T LIKE: I wanted to love this book. As a fat, disabled feminist myself, I REALLY wanted to love this book....but I didn't. I found the style to be unorganized, almost like a series of blog posts mushed together to form a book. Some of the themes also felt forced rather than occurring organically. I also feel like, maybe, she wasn't ready to write the book as she reacts VERY sensitively to any criticism of the work. Please note, I'm not criticizing her experience so much as her writing which was repetitive, clunky, and unorganized.

RECOMMEND FOR: I could see this being a great read for people with no experience reading memoirs. It could also be beneficial for people who don't mind the blog-style of chapters rather than unified work.

NOT RECOMMENDED FOR: Honestly, if you want an honest, well-written look at living in a fat body, there are better memoirs out there.

3 starts out of 5